"The prodigal son returneth" ...

 

... but will this Gunbucket get there …

British Mark V 'Male' Tank

 

… or will he be pinned down – in his quest for the ominously missing and mysterious

"secret service" details. "Mum's the word" for this next Diorama.

 Regards,

 Evans the Spy 😉

British Mark V "Male" Tank

Building Report:

 

Stage 1:

 

The final destination for this next cronological diorama should see me on the East Bank of the

St. Quentin Canal at the begining of October.

The transport that I've chosen to take us there, is the much advertised, appraised (not to mention expensive) Meng Mk V 'Male' Tank. This is eventually to be displayed as an open model which is under repair at the end of the battle. Hence the work of opening up the asbestos lined pannels in order to show off the exellent depiction of the Ricardo engine.

Here's a few pics of my work so far :

A very easy fit with crisp surface detail. It all seemed to good to be true … which is precisely what it turned out to be.

Although I had collected as much information as I could of the Mk. V beforehand, every move I made actually building the thing brought with it more questions.

Here's the 'bucket's list':

  • The front lower edges of the track sides didn't look right, they had sharp corners and not curved as did the originals … maybe some did have this feature but I could'nt find any in the myrad of photo's that I have been scrutinizing.
  • Rear hatches too wide (?)
  • Identifying unit markings ( 4th Btn) were also problematic.
  • The sponsons seemed to be a little on the large size and the unditching beam too long and thin.
  • The interior was lacking the pipes (?) that ran just above and into the floor inside the front sponsons.
  • No detail of the internal lockers.
  • The apparatus of the guns fire direction system were missing as was info on the stowage of the 5 (one spare) Hotchkiss MG's.

Another vague guess from Meng was their "Crib" and it's suggested mode of attachment. Although I wasn't intending to use this device, it seemed an important problem that needed clarifying.

Even after mailing Landships II and Bovinton museum I was left with little to go on. In fairness, the latter did explain that as these vehicles have undergone various repairs/alterations over the years, therefore a sworn accuracy could not be guaranteed. It seems there are no secrets, the explanation is - nobody knows.

 

Where do we go from here?

Well, as regards the internals, even with most of the frontal - mid hatches and doors open, not much of the interior can be seen anyway. So unless you're building an open or cut away version you could confidently  press on without the missing details I've mentioned.

Unhappily for my original "open order" plan there's too much missing to achive the result I'm aiming for. The worst part though, is that the external faults cannot be overseen or corrected.

Feeling like a bit of a mug for being taken in with all the raves about this "amazing" (or should that be A- Maze -In) kit, I've decided to ear mark it for a future project.

 

"Oh shit ... there goes the charabang."

 (The Stranglers)

 

Time to retrace my steps ...

 … and take the long way home.

 

19.07.'18

 

Stage 2:

 

Welcome back to the stoney track.

This time around I'll explain graphically the faults of the Meng kit by comparing it up against it's Takom rival. Starting with the undiching beams - note how long and puny the Meng offering is to Takom's "dod of wood".

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

Here we have Meng's 6 pounder gun and Takom's slightly altered gun control arm. The former model as mentioned during my first attempt is a "little on the large side" overall, a milimeter I can live with ...

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

… this is what I can't. Some may argue that Takom's rear doors are too narrow, but I reckon not.

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

Sponson "Dot-Compare".

Apart from also being grossly oversized, Meng has left off the underside rivets ...

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

… and placed them erroneously down the center edge. Notice Takoms correct bolted depiction. The former has also given their gun muzzles a rifleing, but as the opening is too large this has to be filled in and redrilled.

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report
British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

I'll leave you with the horrible angled front edge of "Meng the Merciless" …

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

… and a glimpse into the "cats cradle" of an internal scratchbuild.

 

27.07.'18

 

 

Stage 3:

 

We hit the road again with a correction this time to a Takom goof - their Mk. IV gun pedestal.

Using the Meng version as a template, I transfered the detail onto my model, correcting the slight size difference accordingly. I'll show you more of these when I've finished painting them. Using this method and (when necessary) adding extra detail from photo's, I gradually built up the interior. I call this "by hook or crook" method: gleaning. Whatever, it can sure save a lot of go it alone scratchbuilding.

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report
British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

Well then, time for me to rest my legs and leave you to get "entangled" with my efforts so far:

 02.08.'18

 

Stage 4:

 

I began this model with some trepidation that when it was finished, only THEN I would get all the "secret" info required.

Luckily, at this stage I obtained a copy of the Tankette magazine (52-1). Therein was an article by a certain Richard Harley that addressed the shortcomings of the Meng "male" kit. To my relief, the errors that I strongly suspected were confirmed in his report, plus a few others that I had not noticed. He also compares this model to the Takom "male", "female" and "hermaphrodite" kits.

Obviously, I cannot reprint any of this but I can mention some of the corrections relevant to my Mk.V "male" as I go along. First, a quick peek through the cab roof. Via the above mentioned article, I learned that the bracket that is attached to the cab and roof, was only meant for tanks destined for Russia. As you can see, I'm in the middle of blanking off the gaps and detail for this fitting.

 

The original Hotchkiss MG's onboard the Mk.V's were a little shorter than the normal length, so I chopped down Takom's offerings to size here.

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

As promised, a sightseeing tour of the completed interior. I know it all looks a bit "ropey" but it's better to show some detail, as opposed to the empty crepuscular rays that shine through the other doors and hatches.The missing small details I mentioned earlier (cables etc.) remain a mystery. Thankfully, those area's cannot be seen on my half opened version. Note release handle for the CRIB device.

 

There's still some problems to be faced, but I'll cross those bridges when I come to them. For now though I'm gonna take a rest and soak my aching feet.

 

10.08.'18

 

Stage 5:

 

This time we'll take a wander around the main body.

Note that the undiching beam has been placed in it's normal position. Some points that I learned from the Tankette mag ...

For Mk.V remove the rivets on the hull sides, just in front of the top edge of the sponsons.

The sponson doors have another Mk.IV feature and that is the old prism vision boxes. These are to be replaced by the typical Mk.V rotating versions. Going by museum pictures, these are the triangular one's that are on the Meng kit. I intend to get "caught up" in these small corrections before priming, just in case some other info winds it's way to me in the meantime.

As you can see, I've changed the normal tracks for Masterclub's 26½ inch wide tracks. Clipping all the links together was an easy dowhill stroll. However, all this was negated by the uphill struggle to fit them to the Takom kit. I'll spare you most of the manic hacking and tearing of the wheels and get 'wired' into the figures for the next outing.

 

15.08.'18

 

Stage 6:

 

Taking a fresh bearing this time to "bash the little people" 😏 This is basically what I'm using ...

MiniArt - Nr. 35009  Soviet Tank Crew At Rest
ICM - Nr. 35694  WWI U.S. Medical Personnel

... along with a couple of Dragon Wehrmacht figures.

 

I've had second thoughts about the figure second from left and decided to scratch build the tank commander instead. The fella with the jerkin is from the Bronco 25 pounder gun crew set.

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

Bits and bobs ...

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

There's still a few "knots and snags" to sort out on them, for now though it's bye-bye.

British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report
British Mark V 'Male' Tank, Diorama 1:35, Building Report

 

Hope you've got some good nerves in your rucksack, 'cos next time we'll be stumbling along a very dark and twisted alley...

Crib

 

 Latest Update: 19.08.'18


Gerne können Sie mich auch auf deutsch

kontaktieren od. einfach einen entsprechenden Kommentar hinterlassen.